Go with 215-45-17. That's what I have and they fit great with the TRD springs (I also have those). The 215-40-17 are good too and are very close to stock maybe a tad shorter. When I got my tires I got a set of each and had each tire mounted up and put them on my car to see which I liked. The 215-45 is deffinately the way to go in my opinion. They also fill the wheel gap a little better. Very nice!!!